So who removed nofollow from their comments ?

 
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (2 votes, average: 3.50 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...
| 9,289 views
 

Lately, I am seeing a lot of blogs from the big boys (like Jeremy Zawodny or Jim Boykin) in our industry, without the nofollow on any of the links in the comments.

As far as I can see, Jeremy doesn’t allow links in the commenters name field, but any other links in the comments, are crawlable and countable links, like in this or this posts.

Moreover, Jim is apparently using some kind of module for this purpose, because I can see links without ANY nofollow in this post, with SOME nofollow’s in this post, and ONLY with nofollow in this post.

I mean you guys know, that I myself removed the nofollow from my comments some time ago (months). I just wanted to give something back to the community. Anyone can download the remove nofollow module I built (it’s very easy to install, just upload and activate) and can have the nofollow in the name/URL field without nofollow, but still keep the nofollow on any URL’s in the comment itself.

I mean these two guys (Jeremy is like Yahoo!’s MySQL geek and Jim is the CEO of Webuildpages, a well known Internet marketing company) certainly know what nofollow is, what can it do for them and stuff like that. If they have disabled the nofollow on their comments, that makes me (us) wonder right ?

I had some views on nofollow in the past. What’s your opinion ? Is the nofollow attribute really important anymore ? Is it preventing spam or not ?

Submit your business or company to Webxperience! and Webotopia directories.
If you found this post useful please Subscribe with Bloglines Add to Technorati Favorites (new windows)
Tags: none
 

27 Comments so far

Razvan said:
September 26th, 2006

Blog spam control can be done through many other methods. Keeping nofollow is just lame (note to self: use Cristian’s plugin to do that when not too lazy :) ).

For blogs the rules are simple:
- if spam delete
- if valid comment, is rude not giving that visitor smthg back

September 27th, 2006

I agree as well. Nofollow should be removed from legit comments. There are so many spam blocking methods available now, this shouldn’t be an issue. Nofollow was only put in place because spammers were starting to attack blogs. Now that we can beat it, we should discontinue its use.

Jim Boykin said:
September 27th, 2006

I’ve got this plug in
http://bronski.net/wordpress-plugins/nonofollow/
and I’ve got it set to remove the no follow after 2 days of being live…just in case I missed some spam, I’ve got 2 days to remove it.

Jim Boykin said:
September 27th, 2006

I brought the no follow topic up when I started blogging:
http://www.jimboykin.com/blog-spam-part-2-the-nofollow-friend-or-enemy/
…and decided that the no follow was not my friend.
http://www.jimboykin.com/giving-the-boot-to-the-nofollow/

September 27th, 2006

Well Jim, I guess you are using Akismet right ? Akismet now catches 100% of spam for me. Really.

I think that plugin of yours is just useless :) But I do love you that you love others back.

September 27th, 2006

I didn’t disable nofollow. It was never there in the first place.

I have reasonable anti-spam stuff in place now (though some slips thru) and have a design in my head for a new one.

September 27th, 2006

What does reasonable anti-spam means Jer ? An inhouse thing built by you ? or that basic “type here Jeremy” captcha ?

September 27th, 2006

Several things:

(1) ignoring trackbacks. they’re 99% spam these days
(2) the “jeremy” thing block most of the bots
(3) mod_security — http://jeremy.zawodny.com/blog/archives/007442.html
(4) a new verification step I’ll add
(5) not using the URLs people supply in the “blog URL” box

Amit Patel said:
September 27th, 2006

Sooo, here we have the nofollow on this blog? :p
Amit patel

September 27th, 2006

Jer :

(1) Done that myself a while ago.
(2) If you say soooo.. As far as I know even much complicated captcha’s are easy to fool.
(3) Mod_security – that’s mambo jumbo to me (not a programmer), but I’m glad it works for you.
(4) Insights ? :P
(5) Now that’s a nice thing and I noticed that. But what if you used it ? Anyone can put their “signature” anyway right ?

Amit: Huh ? :)

September 28th, 2006

Nofollow or not, it’s a tricky question.

I agree that people should get something back when they post a comment, etc. The problem is that without nofollow, a blog comment might be worth just as much SEO juice as as a link that has been carefully selected by the authors of a normal website.

Still, nofollow is better than not giving anything back to the community. I have therefore installed the anti-nofollow on my blog.

greg said:
September 28th, 2006

I took my cue from Jim and removed nofollow back in June – http://greghartnett.com/yesfollow/

Todd Malicoat has an interesting argument on keeping nofollow – http://www.stuntdubl.com/2006/06/03/please-follow/

September 29th, 2006

You’d be surprised at how much spam #2 stops. Sure, some people actually spam by hand, but they’re so small in comparison to the bots out there.

More on #3: http://jeremy.zawodny.com/blog/archives/007442.html

September 29th, 2006

I was considering removing nofollow back in june and it was discussed on my blog http://www.jimwestergren.com/hard-words-from-john-scott/#comment-1699

Most of the replies including from you Cristian :) advised me to leave nofollow on and frankly the only reason for me still having it on is because several of my articles have over 100 comments which will make me break google guidelines and it will almost waste the link juice coming to those articles.

Anyway, that’s my 2 cents.

September 29th, 2006

Thanks Jer for your points.

Jim, I changed my mind a BIT since that article of yours :) I want to offer my readers something in exchange. :)

Arnie said:
December 30th, 2006

I agree with Jim, no follow is not my friend. I find it’s better to deal with cleaning things up rather than not rewarding some good comments.

chris said:
February 21st, 2007

I agree with you, nofollow is not stopping spam. My blogs default had it and I still had to use another tool to prevent spam.

Tomse said:
March 18th, 2007

Same here. I had no nofollow from the beginning and without aksimet i woiuld be buried under the spam-pile.

mukesh said:
March 26th, 2007

The nofollow is a big nonsense. What is the problem in getting a crawlable link from a blog post? After all the idea of google or any search engine for tat matter should be to increase their freaking database size and index as many sites as possible and as quickly as possible at that.

What is the point of indexing a site after five months of existance. All fresh content of the site is gone by then. Google might fight back stating tat it is fighting spam but again spam will be there for as long as the internet is there. Killing good sites (the innocent) for the bad site s is not such a good idea.

What google can be on the other hand is stop this nofollow bullshit and rate sites based on the quality of content.

Closeouts said:
April 18th, 2007

I must say that the nofollow did improve many internet forms, however, I must say I do see some of my links with the nofollow on the google backlinks as well as yahoo,one of them are from http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/ with have nofollows to all his comments.

The Way I see it is simple.

If the site you got the nofollow link is important, and the link is related to the content, you will get credited. However thats only by tought.

spitbook said:
April 20th, 2007

I just increased your rating of this post =)
p.s. I like the “spam me and i’ll spam you back 100x”… lol.. that should scare away spammers.

April 23rd, 2007
April 23rd, 2007

My comment got messed up somehow. Just wanted to say that we got the idea from Andy Beard…

May 4th, 2007

With no follow probably will be more users for posting and for fighting with spam are a lot of other methods

Regards

Hobo SEO said:
June 29th, 2007

We’ve removed it (on our news blog) and encourage clients to remove it. Of course we encourage them to moderate as well.

January 14th, 2008

Thank you!
I think your module is great, no more nofollow in my blog :)

fav said:
July 16th, 2008

nofollow might be useful in romania:))

Leave a reply

Allowed tags (XHTML): <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

RSS Readers & Technorati:

My Subscribers Add to Technorati Favorites
View Cristian Mezei's profile on LinkedIn

Subscribe & Syndication:

RSS Feed at FeedBurner NewsGator Google Bloglines My MSN Add to My Yahoo! Add to FeedLounge Add to My AOL Add to NetVibes Add to NewsBurst Add to Pluck Add to NewsIsFree

Updates by e-mail:

My Blogroll:

Blogs & Forums (RO)

Blogs & Websites

Official Blogs

Social Websites
Powered by Bloglines

Tag Cosmos: Top Tags